Wednesday, May 9, 2018

O Captain! My Captain!


The character John Keating (Robin Williams) in Dead Poet’s Society is one that challenges the traditional approaches to teaching by grasping the attention of his students and allowing them to voice their perspectives and opinions. The movie takes place in the 1950s at an all-boy academy and John is hired by the school to teach a poetry class. The teachers at this school are unlike John and use traditional methods to teach their students. Throughout the movie, a clear divide between John and other teachers is created where he is seen as a teacher who uses progressive ideas and lessons to teach his students. To be effective educators, we need to make learning fun and step away from these traditional approaches that have been used for far too long.

               Early in the movie, we see John’s first encounter with teaching his class. From the very beginning of his role as an educator in this school, he challenges traditional approaches to teaching by saying “Tout le monde” and calling his students out of the classroom. The scene depicts a physical removal from the traditional classroom and is contrasted with the previous scene where several teachers read through a course itinerary and explain what is expected in the classroom. Instead of explaining how he will teach the class or what they will be learning, John begins by talking to students about himself. By giving a brief explanation of who he is, he has created a positive relationship with his students and has shown his students that he is a relatable person who they can talk with.

               Shortly after this scene, we see John teaching his poetry class again. John asks one of his students to read the opening paragraph to the book they are using for the class. The paragraph gives a formula to understanding poetry by asking two questions, which determine a poem’s “greatness”. As the student finishes reading the paragraph, John steps in to say that this approach is “excrement”. He then demands that students rip out that page from their book. Unlike other scenes where teachers have students repeat words back to them, John explains to the students that there is no formula to understanding poetry and that they will learn to think for themselves again. For these students to understand poetry, they need to experience it.


               “We must constantly look at things in a different way”. Approximately thirty minutes into the movie, John is teaching his students about Shakespeare. After John mentions the name, the class lets out groans and sighs. This attitude reflects their understanding of Shakespeare and poetry as something that is boring and repetitive. John then takes on the roles of several Shakespearean characters and acts out a few lines of that these characters share in various accents/impressions. As John progresses through these scenes, students are laughing at the impressions. He is showing his students that they should be experiencing Shakespeare through their own perspective. By laughing and engaging in discussions, John has his students experiencing education. Some of his fellow teachers, however, have students read from a text and demand that they learn in silence.


               A later scene, approximately an hour in to the movie, shows the division between the traditional ways of teaching versus John’s “modern” and progressive approaches. The head-master, Mr. Nolan, has a private discussion with John about his “unorthodox” approaches to teaching. Mr. Nolan asks John about his lesson outside and why his students were marching. After explaining to Mr. Nolan that he was teaching the students about the dangers of conformity, Mr. Nolan tells John that he should go by the curriculum because it is proven to work and that he shouldn’t question it. John then says, “I thought the idea of education was to learn to think for yourself”. This quote summarizes John’s perspective of education and explains why he is teaching his class in certain ways.

              The Ontario Curriculum for Grade 11 and 12 English states that if students “see themselves and others in the texts they study, they will be more engaged in learning and they will also come to appreciate the nature and value of a diverse, multicultural society”. As seen in this movie, teaching students in the English classroom gives them the opportunity to express themselves, understand texts in relation to their own perspectives and experiences, and develop their own knowledge by becoming a part of the learning process. While some of John Keating’s approaches are questionable, many of which violate strict health and safety procedures and practices set out by school boards, it sheds light on some of the possible ways in which educators can engage students and give them the opportunity to become passionate about learning.

O Captain! My Captain!

The character John Keating (Robin Williams) in Dead Poet’s Society is one that challenges the traditional approaches to teaching by graspi...